Welcome to Yo Ho Ho, NABOR!

My Scale for Rating Rum Keep in mind as you read my reviews and ratings that I'm giving you my opinions from a unique perspective. So here's that view of rum that impacts my ratings.

1. I really, really don't like spiced or flavored rum.

2. I've discovered a preference for aging that transcends price.

3. Too much alcohol or too much of a burn straight up hides the quality of rum.

4. I'm surprisingly unswayed by others' opinions of rums, but I am driven to try rums about which others rave.

5. I gave up trying and rating cheaper rums with the exception of some novelty rums.

6. A typical tasting is both straight up and with Diet Coke.

7. I'm not much of a drinker. I don't have more than two drinks in an evening. So I really savor my rum and Diet Cokes.

My Rating Scale 1 to 10, Worst to Best No quibbling over decimal points; although, I have gone back and changed ratings--and reserve the authority to do so again.

The lowest three ratings are just rather poor rums that I don't like.
1 = Pour it out. 2 = Rub it on. 3 = Give it away.

The next three ratings mix with my Diet Coke, and I can be polite about them in company.
4 = Mix it very well. 5 = Mix it. 6 = Accept the gift, but don't regift.

The 7's are a conundrum. They knocked on the door, but the knock on them is typically too much alcohol bite.
7 = Don't turn it down.

These are the rums I hope to get when dining out or in a bar.
8 = Put it on the Top Shelf. 9 = Write it at the Top of the List.


These rums are so far above the others that everyone who tastes them instantly realizes they are special.
10 = Mark it as the Ultimate Rum.

Value Ratings The value ratings are calculated by squaring a rum's rating and dividing by the price for a 750 ml bottle. The very expensive ones don't compete on value. The really bad ones can't overcome their 1 or 2 ratings. This helps find the 8's and 9s that deliver the best taste for the money.

Thursday, March 29, 2012


360 Years of Ligons Pour out and Pore over Rum

“… the drinke of the Iland, which is made of the skimmings of the Coppers, that boyle the Sugar, which they call kill-Divell.”  From A True and Exact History of the Island of Barbados, Richard Ligon, 1657, London.

Kill-Divell is the earliest reference in recorded history to rum.  Based upon Richard Ligon’s travels to Barbados circa 1647. 

Indeed, my very own ancestor Richard was the first to write about rum.  He documented the emergence of kill-divell (aka kill-devil) from its origin in Barbados in the 1600’s. 

Ironically, I discovered this ancestral connection when I Googled my own name to see if this rum blog was being found by the search engines.  Imagine my reaction when the top hits were all Richard Ligon from 1647.  An incredible 360 years after Richard Ligon was tasting and commenting on kill-divell in Barbados, this Ligon began a quest to find the best kill-divell descendent. 

The full quote from Uncle Richard’s book is “We are seldome drye or thirsty, unlesse we overheat our bodyes with extraordinary labour, or drinking strong drinks; as of our English spirits, which we carry over, of french Brandy, or the drinke of the Iland, which is made of the skimmings of the Coppers, that boyle the Sugar, which they call kill-Divell.” 

Apparently not only did I get my interest in rum from Uncle Richard, but also my spelling skills.  I copied and pasted this passage from his book into Word and Spellcheck overloaded.  The only words spelled correctly were capitalized wrong.  A message asked me if I wanted to submit an error report to Microsoft.  The detail in the message said that in proofing spelling,  anytime 20% of the words are incorrect, they assume Spellcheck is malfunctioning.  Hey, this is rum.  I figure 80 proof is normal, right?  

Uncle Richard's book is in the Smithstonian.  This blog--probably headed for another type of institution.  


If you are interested in Richard Ligon's legacy, here's the best article about him.



Sunday, March 18, 2012


Rum: El Dorado 25 Year, 1980 Distillation, April 19, 2007, 
16:19 HoursGuyana


Rating: 10     Proof:  80

A gift from Steve Curtis, Edustructures, to commemorate the acquisition of the National Transcript Center, March 13, 2009.  Everyone who tries it knows right off that it's special.

 Value Rating: .29  Very Low


Typical Price:  $350/750 ml
Seems the rating scale needs to go up to 36 in order for this rum to be the highest value.

Rum: Ron Abuelo Centuria, Reserva de la FamiliaPanama

Rating: 9     Proof:  80

A blended rum with rums aged in white oak for as long as 30 years.  I had to get past the bite to really enjoy the aged flavor.  Didn't expect that from the Esquire article which made this out to be possibly the best rum.  Can't quite compete with El Dorado 25.  

 Value Rating: .58  Moderate


Typical Price:  $140/750 ml




Rum: El Dorado, 21 Year Old Rum, Finest DemeraraGuyana

Rating: 9     Proof:  80

Best of the aged--23 years.  Best of the "first crush of the sugar cane."  This one really suits my taste.

 Value Rating: 1.40  Moderate


Typical Price:  $58/750 ml




Rum: Ron Zacapa, 23 AnosGuatemala

Rating: 9     Proof:  80

Best of the aged--23 years.  Best of the "first crush of the sugar cane."  This one really suits my taste.

 Value Rating: 1.93  Very Good


Typical Price:  $42/750 ml




Rum: Mocambo, Aged 20 YearsVeracruz, Mexico

Rating: 9     Proof:  80

Kyle's '07 Christmas gift.  A real find.  Unique bottle.  "Ho, ho, ho, and a bottle of rum," says Santa.  Then in 2011, Clint and Aly give me another bottle for Christmas.  So this is officially the "Spirit of Christmas."

 Value Rating: 2.31  Great


Typical Price:  $35/750 ml





Rum: Myers's Legend, Aged 10 YearsJamaica

Rating: 9     Proof:  80

Excellent.  Dark.  Can't throw away the great bottle.  Can you get refills?

 Value Rating: 1.88  Outstanding 


Typical Price:  $43/750 ml       




Rum: Bacardi Ron 8 Anos, Ron Reserva SuperiorPuerto Rico

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

Dark.  Great.  This one started the quest for the best rum--Port Aransas--Thanksgiving, 2006.  This is my Port A rum  Goes best with family and shrimp.

 Value Rating: 3.56  Outstanding         


Typical Price:  $18/750 ml        




Rum: Ron Barcelo, Gran Anejo, Dominican Republic

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

"A blend of the finest Dominican rums patently settled in oak barrels."  Very smooth.  May be under-rated at 8.

 Value Rating: 3.37  Outstanding   


Typical Price:  $19/750 ml


Rum: Pecan Street Rum, Pflugerville, Texas

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

I love pecans.  Very light.  Tasty.  Lacks that aged quality.  Pfloored Treaty Oak Rum out of the state.  

 Value Rating: 3.20  Outstanding 


Typical Price:  $20/750 ml




Rum: Aniversario Pampero Reserva Exclusiva, Ron Anejo, Venezuela

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

Very close to being a top-list rum.  Could be aged a few more years.  Paper or plastic?  No!  Leather bag.  Classy.  This is a favorite of the Culp brothers--Clint & Wes.  

 Value Rating: 2.56  Great


Typical Price:  $25/750 ml




Rum: Pyrat, XO ReserveBritish West Indies

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

Excellent.  Lighter, Tastier.  Great cork.  Use as a floatation devise in case of a water landing.  Patron's rum comes from a good family.  The Pyrat asks, "Arrrrr you ready to RUMble?"  

 Value Rating: 2.29  Great


Typical Price:  $28/750 ml




Rum: 10 CaneTrinidad

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

The bar at the old train station in Cheyenne, Wyoming, had this new rum.  Found it in Anchorage, too.  A new category is needed for this rum--first pressing, no molasses, no aging.  This is now what I look for in bars, because the really good aged rum just can't be found.

 Value Rating: 2.13  Great


Typical Price:  $30/750 ml




Rum: El Dorado 15 Year, Finest Demerara, Guyana

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

Noticeably better than 12 year.

 Value Rating: 2.00  Great


Typical Price:  $32/750 ml




Rum: Zaya Gran Reserva, Aged 12 YearsGuatemala

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

Light.  Tasty.  Distilled from "pure sugar cane."  Very sugary aroma.

 Value Rating: 1.94  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $33/750 ml




Rum: Oronoco, Brazil

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

Compares to 10 Cane but with a different flavor.

 Value Rating: 1.83  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $35/750 ml


Rum: Mount Gay Extra Old, BlendedBarbados

Rating: 8     Proof:  86

First taste was great.

 Value Rating: 1.68  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $38/750 ml




Rum: Rhum Barbancourt, Vieilli 15 Annos, 
Port au Prince, Haiti

Rating: 8     Proof:  86

Matured in selected bourbon casks.  Quite a bite after 21 years.  

 Value Rating: 1.64  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $39/750 ml




Rum: Zafra, Master Reserve, Aged 21 YearsPanama

Rating: 8     Proof:  80

Matured in selected bourbon casks.  Quite a bite after 21 years.  

 Value Rating: 1.33  Moderate 


Typical Price:  $48/750 ml

Rum: 
Flor de Cana Centenario 21, 
Nicaragua


Rating: 8     Proof:  80

Clint's gift--excellent taste!  21 is for the century not the aging.  Aged 15 years.  


Value Rating: .93  Low  


Typical Price:  $69/750 ml


Rum: Gosling's Black Seal, Bermuda


Rating: 7     Proof:  80

Dark taste--interesting flavor from the barrel. 

 Value Rating: 2.58  Excellent  


Typical Price:  $19/750 ml




Rum: Brugal Anejo, 5 Year Old, Dominican Republic
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

Tasted at Legal Seafood restaurant in Boston (November '08) Described in flier as "Dark amber with hints of coconut and vanilla, this is a rich buttery, intensely flavored rum."

 Value Rating: 2.58  Excellent  


Typical Price:  $19/750 ml




Rum: Appleton Estate Extra, Aged 12 Years, Jamaica
Rating: 7     Proof:  86

Screw cap.  Maybe the extra 6 proof didn't help.

 Value Rating: 1.96  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $25/750 ml

Rum: El Dorado 12 Year, Special Reserve, Guyana
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

One of the youngest of the aged El Dorados--clearly a junior rum--still very good.

 Value Rating: 1.88  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $26/750 ml

Rum: Tommy Bahama Golden Sun, Barbados
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

An excellent vacation rum for the beach.  Better than Myers's Dark--should replace it in bars--won't, I bet.

 Value Rating: 1.75  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $28/750 ml

Rum: Toucano Espirito Puro da Natureza, Brazil
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

"…born of the first flavorful crush of the sugar cane."

 Value Rating: 1.63  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $30/750 ml

Rum: Matusalem Gran Reserva, El Espiritu de Cuba Solera Blender 15, Dominican Republic
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

Solera Blender 15 "Hint of smokey smoothness"

 Value Rating: 1.53  Very Good  


Typical Price:  $32/750 ml

Rum: Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva, 12 Years, Venezuela
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

Very smooth.  Flowery smell.  Ranks in there with other 12 year rums.

 Value Rating: 1.48  Moderate  


Typical Price:  $33/750 ml

Rum: Depaz Blue Cane, Rhum Aricole, Martinique
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

 Value Rating: 1.40  Moderate  


Typical Price:  $35/750 ml

Rum: Vizcaya VXOP, Cuban Formula Rum Cask No. 21, Dominican Republic
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

Cuban Formula Rum Cask No. 21.  


Value Rating: 1.20  Moderate  


Typical Price:  $41/750 ml

Rum: Gosling's Family Reserve Rum, Bottle #2095/07 Old Rum Black Seal, Bermuda/Bardstown, KY
Rating: 7     Proof:  80

Pricey, impressive presentation in the bottle. 


Value Rating: .82  Low    


Typical Price:  $60/750 ml

Saturday, March 17, 2012


Rum: Santa Teresa Gran Reserva, Ron AnejoVenezuela
Rating: 6     Proof:  80

Not much taste, but acceptable for mixing. This one needs to be tried again.


Value Rating:   1.20    Moderate


Typical Price:   $30/750 ml